Why Differentiate Reading Instruction?

"A full 70 percent of U.S. middle and high schoolpurposes. This is the reason why we need to abandon
students require differentiated instruction which isone-text-for-all-learners and bring multiple texts into our
instruction targeted at their individual strengths andclassrooms. Using multiple texts enables each student
weaknesses."--Reading Next, page 8. This quote, fromto learn at his or her instructional level. This way, each
a study completed in 2004 by Catherine Snow andstudent can continue to improve and develop the
Gina Biancarosa, both researchers at Harvardreading skill and stamina to prepare for the dramatic
University, illustrates the need to address the diversitychanges in the job market in this and the next century.
of literacy skills among adolescent learners. The divideAt this point, you might be wondering exactly what
that we teachers observe in the middle grades anddifferentiated reading instruction is?
middle school becomes apparent when school districtsDifferentiation is a way of teaching and not a
require all students to learn from grade level contentprepackaged program or the same workbook for
textbooks and literature anthologies that most studentsevery students. When you differentiate reading
can't read. Statistics from a study by the U.S.instruction, you need to know your students so well
Department of Education pointed out that more thanthat you can plan learning experiences that will improve
eight million American students are struggling readersstudents' reading, thinking, recall, and writing. What
who read two or more years below grade levelfollows are some key principles that form the
(2003). Data also shows that high school students infoundation of differentiating reading instruction.
the lowest 25 percent of their class are 20 timesFirst: Ongoing, formative assessment invites you to
more likely to drop out of school than excellent andcontinually pinpoint students' strengths as well as areas
proficient readers.of need in order to match instruction and learning
Right now, too many middle and high schools acrossexperiences to each student.
our nation place students in a curriculum whereSecond: Diverse learners in your class have varied
everyone reads the same text and completes thelevels of reading, writing, thinking, speaking, and problem
same assignments. It's not working, and here are somesolving skills and expertise, requiring that you develop
reasons. Little to no progress in reading scores frominstruction that reaches every learner.
the National Assessment of Education Progress (theThird: Partner and small group work whose
NAEP) which is the nation's report card has beenmembership changes as students show you they
made since 1992. At this rate, the number of adultsneed reteaching or are ready to move forward.
who don't have the education and literacy skills toProblem solving places the focus in differentiated
work in twenty-first century technological jobs willclasses on issues, themes, and concepts which allows
continue to increase. Add to the NAEP results and theteachers to focus on big ideas using multiple or
studies completed by Snow and Biancarosa and thedifferent texts instead of everyone reading one novel
U.S. State Department, the daily frustrations you and Ior textbook.
experience trying to reach classes of diverse learnersFinally, choice is at the heart of differentiation. In addition
with one set of textbooks, then the need to exploreto mandated and required tasks, teachers offer their
other methods of instruction becomes obvious.students choices in reading and writing tasks that
In any middle grade or middle school class there will berelate to a unit.
groups of students who read below, on or near, andSo to differentiate reading instruction teachers need to
above grade level, and you and I need to differentiatethink of the purpose of assessments--they are a way
reading instruction to meet each student's uniqueto gain in sights into their students' learning. When
needs. This is the heart of differentiating readingteachers know their students and respond to their
instruction. This is the reason that teachers andstrengths and needs, they can support and maximize
researchers have begun to look closely at ways tolearning and reach every reader.
help adolescents read and write for many different